Vatsonga Machangani Condemns Personal Attacks Against TUT Vice-Chancellor. In a powerful response to a series of recent allegations, the Vatsonga Machangani Forum has come forward in strong support of Professor Tinyiko Maluleke, the respected Vice-Chancellor of Tshwane University of Technology (TUT). The Forum has condemned what it describes as “personal and unfounded attacks” against Professor Maluleke. These attacks are linked to a complaint lodged with the Public Protector by individuals claiming TUT has undermined the proposed University of Mining and Agriculture in Sekhukhune.
The controversy, sparked by claims from William Maphutha, has evolved into a broader debate about educational development, tribal identity, and the urgent need for collaboration rather than conflict.
Accusations Against TUT and Its Leadership
The controversy began when William Maphutha, who alleges to represent a Sekhukhune-based organisation and operates Batsumi Pty Ltd, accused TUT of sabotaging efforts to establish a new university in Sekhukhune. According to Maphutha, this initiative was formalised in a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) signed in 2021 between the Bapedi Royal Kingdom and TUT.
He claimed that TUT hijacked the project without transparent communication or consultation with relevant stakeholders, further accusing Professor Maluleke of unethical conduct and falsely labeling him as someone with hidden personal interests linked to Giyani.
Vatsonga Machangani Forum Firm Response
The Vatsonga Machangani Forum has flatly rejected these allegations, calling them “baseless, tribalistic, and damaging.” In an official statement, the Forum emphasized that the accusations against Professor Maluleke lack any substantial proof and appear to be politically or personally motivated.
“The recent personal attacks on Professor Tinyiko Maluleke are not only unfounded but also deliberately aimed at undermining the integrity of an esteemed academic and leader,” – Vatsonga Machangani Forum
The Forum warned against attempts to turn what should be a collaborative developmental issue into a tribal dispute. They argued that such actions threaten the future of educational development in Limpopo and South Africa at large.
History of the Giyani Campus Campaign
Contrary to claims that the Giyani Campus is a recent political creation, the Vatsonga Machangani community has been advocating for a university in Giyani since as far back as 2004. Their efforts have included consistent lobbying, community initiatives, and engagement with stakeholders.
“Our community has been calling for a university in Giyani since 2004—long before political promises were made. This is a fight for our future, not personal gain,” – Vatsonga Machangani Forum
The campaign, led by community champions such as Dr Ndhambi of the Khatsani Education Foundation, highlights a grassroots movement committed to improving educational access in the historically underdeveloped Giyani region.
Why the Giyani and Sekhukhune Regions Deserve Universities
South Africa continues to face a critical shortage of university spaces, particularly in rural provinces such as Limpopo. Both Giyani and Sekhukhune are deserving of their own higher education institutions to address this gap.
| District | Estimated Population | University Access | Major Campaigns |
|---|---|---|---|
| Giyani | 250,000+ | Limited (TVET only) | Giyani Campus by TUT |
| Sekhukhune | 1.2 million+ | Limited | University of Mining & Agriculture |
| Polokwane | 700,000+ | Full access (UNILIM, TVETs) | – |
As shown above, both Giyani and Sekhukhune remain underserved in terms of full-fledged university access. The expansion of TUT and the proposed University of Mining and Agriculture are essential to unlocking regional potential.
Dismissing Tribalism in Favor of Development
The Vatsonga Machangani Forum strongly criticized the use of tribal narratives to divide communities and derail legitimate educational initiatives.
“Despite opposition rooted in tribalism and fears of change, the economic potential of the Giyani campus is undeniable,” – Forum Statement
It stressed that Professor Maluleke has served in various academic and leadership roles with integrity and excellence, and tribal identity should not be used to question his leadership.
Clarifying the University of Mining and Agriculture Project
TUT has acknowledged the importance of establishing a campus in Sekhukhune, and records show that the university has formally engaged in the process. A letter dated April 12, 2025, confirms the appointment of a partner to conduct a market feasibility study for the Sekhukhune Campus.
“Claims that TUT hijacked the project are unfounded. The university is committed to serving all communities and is engaging in official processes to develop the Sekhukhune campus.” – Vatsonga Machangani Forum
The naming or branding of the Sekhukhune University of Mining and Agriculture is still a matter for formal discussion and government regulation—not public media narratives or personal campaigns.
Refuting Personal Attacks on Professor Tinyiko Maluleke
The most alarming part of the recent allegations is the direct attack on Professor Maluleke, with phrases like “manipulator of truth” and “thief” being used irresponsibly.
“Claims that Professor Maluleke is a ‘thief’ or ‘manipulator of truth’ are reckless and baseless. He has dedicated his career to education and community upliftment.” – Forum Statement
These kinds of statements are not only defamatory but could severely impact trust in the leadership of a crucial institution like TUT. The Vatsonga Machangani Forum rightly defends his reputation and calls for factual, respectful discourse.
The Bigger Picture
South Africa is in urgent need of collaborative solutions to build the next generation of professionals, engineers, agriculturalists, and researchers. Pitting one community against another only serves to delay progress.
| Statistic | Data |
|---|---|
| Annual Matric Graduates | ~900,000 |
| Public University Spaces Available | ~500,000 |
| Higher Ed Shortfall | ~400,000+ |
| Limpopo University Projects Needed | 2+ New Institutions |
Both Giyani and Sekhukhune must be viewed not as rivals, but as essential partners in the future of higher education in Limpopo. More institutions mean more jobs, more skills, and more development.
A Call for Social Cohesion and Government Action
The Vatsonga Machangani Forum urged the Limpopo provincial government and national stakeholders to step in and facilitate social cohesion.
“We call on authorities to foster social cohesion and support our communities’ development efforts instead of fueling tribal divisions,” – Forum Statement
Such cohesion would enable the successful rollout of university campuses in both regions, ensuring that no community is left behind due to politics or prejudice.
Conclusion
This situation serves as a powerful reminder of the stakes involved in South Africa’s educational development. Petty rivalries and tribal rhetoric have no place in discussions that affect millions of young people.
